Come Relax & Unwind

Your tranquil getaway on Shelter Island.

The songs of the birds and the sunlight shimmering off the water greet you during your mornings at our guesthouse. House on Chase Creek is your getaway in the heart of Shelter Island Heights.

Welcome Home

Come for the comfort, stay for the historic charm.

Enjoy the enchanting classicness of our original pinewood floors and antiques while having all the modern amenities and conveniences you need. The flowers of spring, the radiant colors of fall, and the stillness of winter makes our house the perfect place to visit year-round.

No matter the occasion, we are always there to provide a quiet and relaxing place for you to get the best sleep of your life.

Book Now Learn more

The Location

A walking distance from the North Ferry port, the train, bicycle rentals, hiking trails, the beach, restaurants, and more, we are the perfect home base for exploring both the North Fork and the Hamptons.

Take the train from Manhattan, board the ferry from Greenport (8 min), and take a short stroll from the North Ferry port (5 min) to arrive at the House.

Book Now Directions

About Shelter Island

Early in the seventeenth century, the beautiful Island known as Manhansack-aha-quash-awamock (“an island sheltered by islands”) was the peaceful home of the Manhanset tribe of Indians.

Once bought for 1,600lbs of sugar, to being ransacked in the War of 1812, to now, Shelter Island is a favorite getaway location to classic American style.

Enjoy the beautiful waterways, go for a swim at Cresent Beach, play a round of golf at the Country Club, go for a bike ride, hike the trails, or visit the shops while you’re here at the “island sheltered by islands”.

  • Classic old world Shelter Island vibe!

    Boutique inn with 4 units is always welcoming and the location so unique. Classic old world Shelter Island vibe! Beautiful sunroom offering coffee, tea, filtered water, coffee machine, glassware, cutlery, mugs and a microwave available. Close to Dering Harbor and North Ferry. Walk on to ferry to visit Greenport on foot. Easy walking distance to many restaurants and the Carousel at Mitchell Park on water. Leave your car behind and save on ferry. Drive to almost any location on Shelter Island 10-20 minutes.

  • Everything you need is there.

    I live in NYC and it was finally time to visit Shelter Island, which I had never been to. Bill, a friendly native of Shelter Island, knows everything about the area. He promptly managed to accommodate me for a few weeknights, despite being booked solid. A pleasant surprise, the Inn is in what appears to be the best location in Shelter Heights. Everything you need is there. I will definitely return to House on Chase Creek. Thank you Bill for your kind hospitality!

    Flavia C.
  • The inn is beautifully maintained and our room was extremely clean.

    The House on Chase Creek is a hidden gem on the island. The inn is beautifully maintained and our room was extremely clean. Our host, Bill, was very attentive and gave us great suggestions of things to do on our first visit to Shelter Island. He even set up the fireplace in our room for us every night so all we had to do was light a match and enjoy. I can’t say enough good things about Bill and his wonderful B&B. We were planning a return trip before we even left!

    Kat K.

Stay in the loop

Don’t miss out on specials, sales, and events.

Find us here

Get in touch

    Previous Next
    Test Caption
    Test Description goes like this